Why It Never Feels Like Enough — And What to Do About It

Have you ever had a day or a week where rationally you know you did enough, but the voice in your head is loudly shouting about the steps you didn’t do, or the chocolate treat you ate? 

I had this situation with a client recently and thought it might be useful for others to share. My client, I’m going to call her Erica for this article, has been struggling for a few weeks. Feeling overwhelmed and like she just couldn’t commit to taking action. Instead of letting her give up, we talked it through and set up an action plan. Three non-negotiables, nothing else mattered, tick the three boxes and you’re winning. The three non-negotiables were: 

  1. Protein at breakfast 
  2. 3+ fruit/veg servings daily 
  3. 10 squats and/or wall push ups in the morning 

We scrapped off all talk of calories, protein at every meal, planned workouts, steps, and other activity. I wanted to give her a chance to believe in herself, to tick the boxes and feel good about it. 

But what happened? 

She ticked the boxes. Erica had a high protein breakfast every single day, she ate three meals each day with protein, and a minimum of 5 fruit and veg every day. She did her morning exercises, most days completing both squats and push ups, and some days two sets. From my point of view Erica exceeded every expectation I had of her, I was buzzing, really happy. 

Erica on the other hand, was not happy. She couldn’t celebrate ticking the boxes, because the voice in her head was telling her she had failed. 

“You’ve drank two bottles of wine during the week of course you’re not on plan”

“Your step count is too low”

“You’re doing the bare minimum, it’s not enough” 

Erica took action. She improved hugely from where she was two weeks earlier, but the inner monologue shouted louder that it’s not enough.

What is the Inner Monologue?

Most of us have an inner monologue of some kind, for some people it’s a voice, for others its visual in the way of images or colours, even feelings, for some people it’s constant for others it only shows up occasionally. It is a way for us to rationalise the world around us, cement memories, self-regulate, plan, and problem solve. But, for some people, the inner monologue is highly critical and problematic. 

For those people that have a negative inner monologue, it can be incredibly destructive and make progressing in every area of life, including losing weight and getting fitter incredibly difficult. That negative voice shows up and pulls the pin on any happiness or achievement you may have created, and may sound like phrases such as:

  • “You should have done more”
  • “That doesn’t count”
  • “You’ve messed it up now”
  • “You’ll never stick to anything”

If you have this negative inner monologue, I am sure this relates right now. If you don’t, can you imagine how this would impact every area of your life, if there was an alternate universe in your head that constantly criticises everything you do. Even when you tick the boxes, it picks things that weren’t on the list and points out why it wasn’t enough, and you’re fooling yourself to think that it was. 

Why Your Inner Voice is Keeping You Stuck 

I often talk about the ‘all or nothing’ mentality of dieting, and how it has been bought about by the dieting industry. The need to be perfect or you’ve failed, there is no middle ground. And popular diets, do indeed perpetuate this thinking. For those of us with a negative inner monologue those ideals, are seized up, and spat back out at us b y the voice in our head. 

The problem is that it’s impossible to be perfect. Life happens. We set unrealistic, unachievable standards, then out inner monologue criticises when don’t achieve them. So, what happens. You give up. And giving up is what is stopping you from getting results, and maintaining them. 

There is no problem with your ability to lose weight. Your metabolism, peri-menopause, the fact that you’re now 50 … 

The problem is that you give up. 

And you give up because the voice in your head is overly critical. 

Erica’s example perfectly demonstrates that:

  • I set three targets for the week
  • Erica achieved those three targets and more 
  • Erica’s inner monologue moved the goal posts, changed the rules, and told her that she had not done enough, leaving her feeling like she had failed and might as well give up. 

Yes, she wanted to give up, because she felt like she hadn’t done enough. 

Doing More Is Not The Solution 

It is tempting to try and out work the inner monologue, do more, try harder, but that’s not sustainable and you eventually give up, feeling worse that you did when you started, and even more convince that nothing will work for you. You will never lose weight. You will never feel good in your clothes. You will never feel like yourself again. 

Doing more is not a solution. Neither is giving up. 

It’s time to start listening. 

Notice when the chatter starts. 

Notice what it is saying. 

Notice the tone, the words, the phrase. 

Notice when it happens, are you tired, hungry, stressed, emotional. 

Creating space and awareness of the voice is the first step toward challenging it, and breaking free from what feels like it’s vicelike grip. 

How to Challenge Your Inner Monologue

You have been listening to that voice, probably since childhood, no bullshit it’s going to take some time and practice to break free, and it’ll still be in the background making the toughest days a little bit harder. But learning some strategies, starting with listening and noticing, can help you to challenge the voice, ride the wave, and stick the course. 

Here are 5 simple strategies that may help, of course I am a personal trainer and nutritionist, if this is deeply affecting your daily life you may also like to consult a therapist to help further support you to break free from that negative voice in your head. 

  1. Name it: Give the negative voice in your head a funny persona and name, It is hard to take something humorous seriously, so when the voice starts try and clearly picture your ‘Cynical Cynthia’ in her funny clothes, and her squeaky voice, make it resonate with you, something you would find funny, and hard to take seriously.
  2. Reframe: When “I didn’t do enough” plays on repeat in your head. Can you reframe that to “What did I do well?” This question isn’t asking for perfection. It is asking you to identify something positive.
  3. Evidence check: When the negative talk is loud, can you ask yourself rationally is that really true? What evidence is there that I failed compared to the evidence that I was working toward my goals?
  4. Talk to yourself like a friend: What would you say to a friend, partner, daughter in this situation. Would you tell them they had failed or would you point out why that is factually incorrect? 
  5. Neutral over positive: Instead of expecting positivity, universal acceptance from the voice in your head that’s been a neggy influence for years. Strive for neutral, balance. I did A,B,C well, X and Y could have been better, but overall it wasn’t bad. 
  6. Set good enough standards: This is inbuilt into support from me as part of my Never Diet Again club or 1:1 coaching. We don’t set unrealistic, unachievable targets, we set range targets that span basic achievable, will get results, to exceeds expectations, results will be faster. An example would be 2 strength sessions per week of 20 minutes each is a basic minimum to see results, gold standard would be 4 x 30 minute sessions. 

What Changes If You Implement This? 

Let’s go back to Erica here, she was on the verge of giving up, she felt like she would never lose weight, and never feel good again, she was destined to be miserable. We talked a lot about the inner voice, she worked on noticing it, then gently challenging it. We were in daily contact (the benefit of a supportive coach, apply here!), I called her out when needed, I was gentle when needed, I was the friend that injected some realism. She started to trust me more than the voice in her head, she believed when I told her she was succeeding, she started to get some results, and slowly she started to believe and challenge the voice herself. 

Has she reached her goals: not yet

Will she: hell yes 

Is every day a good day: no 

Is she messaging me every day saying she can’t do it, she’s giving up: no 

It’s not easy, but working on challenging the negative inner monologue can help you to achieve consistency, it can help you to break free from the ‘all or nothing thinking’ that is keeping you stuck in the cycle of yoyo dieting. 

If this has resonated, and you’d like someone on your team helping you to challenge the inner critic that’s holding you back drop me message or fill in the application form I’d love to help.